While gender mandates have propelled more women into political roles in Mexico, the recent case of Mexico City mayoral candidate Clara Brugada raises questions about the balance between gender equality and effective governance
Photo: FB-ClaraBrugadaM (Edit: LatamPost)
Latin American Post Staff
Escucha este artículo
Leer en español: El desafío del mandato de género en México: ir más allá de la paridad para una gobernanza eficaz
Unveiling Gender Complexities in Mexican Politics
The recent leapfrogging of the most popular contender, Omar Garcia Harfuch, for the Mexico City mayoral candidate position in favor of Clara Brugada within Mexico's National Regeneration Movement (MORENA) party, highlights the complexities of gender mandates in politics. While the push for gender parity is undoubtedly a commendable endeavor, we must examine the potential pitfalls that come with it.
Mexico's gender parity rules have made significant strides in women's political representation. Since 2018, the country's Congress has achieved a balanced 50-50 split between men and women. Furthermore, the number of female state governors has risen from just one five years ago to nine out of 31. These accomplishments should not be downplayed; they represent a significant shift in a socially conservative country.
Balancing Act: Gender Mandates and Meritocracy
However, the recent selection of Clara Brugada as MORENA's mayoral candidate in Mexico City, despite polling showing a significant lead for Omar Garcia Harfuch, raises questions about the potential drawbacks of gender mandates. While such mandates aim to ensure equal representation, they can sometimes lead to decisions that prioritize gender over merit.
In this case, party-commissioned polling indicated that Garcia Harfuch had a nearly 14-point victory margin over Brugada—however, the party prioritized gender parity over the candidate with the highest support. While gender representation is essential, it should not come at the expense of qualified and popular candidates who may happen to be male.
Furthermore, the enforcement of gender mandates can lead to contentious issues. For example, in the past, some male candidates falsely claimed to be transgender women in an attempt to bypass the rules. Such instances undermine the mandates' integrity and divert attention and resources away from legitimate gender equality efforts.
Challenging Decisions: Striking a Balance
It is crucial to acknowledge the positive impact that gender mandates have had in bringing more women into political leadership roles. Still, we must also recognize that achieving gender parity does not guarantee effective governance. Gender mandates should not be viewed as a silver bullet that automatically leads to better leadership or outcomes.
As Mexican writer Margo Glantz rightly pointed out, having women in positions of power is essential, but it is not enough. Effective governance requires capable, knowledgeable, dedicated individuals to serve their constituents. Gender should not be the sole criterion for selecting candidates; their qualifications, experience, and ability to address their communities' challenges should also be considered.
The case of Guerrero state Governor Evelyn Salgado serves as a reminder of the limitations of gender mandates. She was chosen as a last-minute replacement for her father and faced criticism for her response to Hurricane Otis, which devastated the region. Gender parity alone did not guarantee effective leadership in this instance.
Beyond Quotas: Fostering Lasting Change
While gender mandates have paved the way for increased women's political representation, we must remember that actual progress requires more than just meeting quotas. It necessitates creating a culture where women are encouraged to participate in politics and have access to education and resources, and merit is the primary criterion for selection.
Moreover, gender equality efforts should extend beyond politics and into all aspects of society. To achieve lasting change, we must address the root causes of gender inequality, challenge traditional gender roles, and create an environment where women have equal opportunities and are valued for their contributions.
In conclusion, gender mandates have played a crucial role in advancing women's representation in Mexican politics, and their impact should not be underestimated. However, we must balance achieving gender parity and ensuring that qualified and popular candidates are not sidelined solely based on gender. Effective governance requires leaders who are representative and capable of addressing the complex challenges facing their communities. Gender equality efforts should be comprehensive and extend beyond politics to create a more equitable society.